Determining Liability in a Side-Impact Collision: Who Is at Fault?
Miami's Premier Black-Owned Law Firm
Passionate | Principled | Advocacy for the People of South Florida
The Complexity of Side-Impact Crashes
Miami is a city defined by its vibrant energy, but that same energy translates into some of the most congested and dangerous intersections in the country. Among the most devastating types of accidents seen on South Florida roads is the side-impact collision—often referred to as a "T-bone" or "broadside" accident. These crashes are particularly dangerous because the sides of vehicles offer far less protection to occupants than the front or rear bumpers, which are designed with substantial crumple zones.
If you have been hit from the side, you are likely dealing with more than just vehicle damage. You may be facing mounting medical bills, physical pain, and the stress of being unable to work. At Lett Law Firm, we believe that when an injury isn't your fault, you shouldn't have to bear the costs.
Founding attorney Ariel Lett, Esq. brings a unique advantage to your case. Having practiced at large defense firms, he has a deep understanding of how insurance companies operate and the tactics they use to devalue claims. Whether you were struck in a busy Coral Gables intersection or a quiet neighborhood in Liberty City, our multi-award-winning firm is here to ensure you are not taken advantage of.
Understanding Fault in Side-Impact Accidents
A common misconception is that the person who does the "hitting" is always the one at fault. In side-impact collisions, this is not necessarily true. Determining liability requires a meticulous evaluation of who had the right of way and who breached their duty of care on the road.
The Right of Way Principle
Fault in a side-impact accident almost always boils down to who violated the right of way. In Miami’s complex traffic landscape, these accidents typically occur in three scenarios:
- Running a Red Light or Stop Sign: If a driver fails to stop at a signal and broadsides a vehicle legally proceeding through the intersection, they are clearly at fault.
- Left-Hand Turns: This is a frequent cause of T-bone accidents. A driver making a left turn must yield to oncoming traffic. If they turn into the path of a vehicle going straight, the turning driver is usually liable.
- Pulling Out of a Driveway or Side Street: Drivers entering a main road must wait for a safe gap. If they pull out and are hit by a car traveling on the main thoroughfare, the driver who pulled out is typically responsible.
Florida’s Comparative Negligence Law
It is important to understand that Florida operates under a modified comparative negligence system. This means that more than one person can be found at fault for an accident. For example, if you were hit from the side by someone who ran a red light, but you were also speeding at the time, a jury might find you partially responsible.
As of recent changes in Florida law, if you are found to be more than 50% at fault for the accident, you are barred from recovering any compensation. This makes having an experienced advocate like Ariel Lett essential to prove the other party’s primary negligence.
Key Factors Used to Prove Liability
Insurance companies are notorious for trying to shift blame to avoid paying out settlements. Ariel Lett’s background in insurance defense allows Lett Law Firm to anticipate these defenses before they are even raised. We look at several critical pieces of evidence to build your case:
1. The Police Report
While a police report isn't always the final word in a civil case, it is a vital starting point. Officers at the scene will document the position of the cars, witness statements, and whether any citations were issued for traffic violations.
2. Physical Evidence and Vehicle Damage
The point of impact tells a story. For instance, if the front of Car A hit the rear-side door of Car B, it might suggest that Car B was already nearly through the intersection when Car A failed to stop. We often work with accident reconstruction experts to analyze skid marks and "black box" data from the vehicles.
3. Surveillance and Dashcam Footage
In a tech-heavy city like Miami, many intersections are monitored by traffic cameras, and many businesses have security footage. We move quickly to secure this video evidence before it is looped over or deleted.
4. Witness Testimony
Neutral third parties who saw the accident occur are often the most reliable sources for determining who had the green light or who was distracted by their phone.
The Costs of a Side-Impact Injury
Side-impact collisions frequently result in severe, life-altering injuries. Because there is so little space between the door and the passenger, the force of the impact is transferred directly to the human body. At Lett Law Firm, we represent clients suffering from:
- Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBI): Caused by the head striking the side window or door frame.
- Spinal Cord Injuries: Resulting from the lateral "whiplash" motion of the torso.
- Internal Organ Damage: Specifically to the liver, spleen, and ribs on the side of the impact.
- Spinal Cord Injury and Broken Bones: Particularly the pelvis, hips, and shoulders.
These injuries aren't just physical; they are financial. Between hospital stays, physical therapy, and the inability to continue to work, a "simple" accident can lead to financial ruin. Our education-first approach helps mitigate these hardships by guiding you through every step of the litigation process.
Why Choose Lett Law Firm?
When you choose Ariel Lett, you are choosing an attorney who has seen the law from both sides of the bench. As a former federal law clerk, Mr. Lett managed complex procedural and substantive legal issues for the U.S. District Court. This high-level experience, combined with his knowledge of insurance company "Bad Faith" tactics, makes him one of the most trusted personal injury lawyers in South Florida.
The Lett Law Advantage:
- Inside Knowledge: We know how insurance companies evaluate and try to defend cases because we used to be in those rooms.
- Aggressive Advocacy: We are principled and passionate about getting "The People" the justice they deserve.
- No Upfront Costs: We offer a FREE consultation and work on a contingency fee basis—you don't pay unless we recover compensation for you.
Let Us Fight For You
Determining who is at fault when a car hits you from the side is rarely as simple as it seems on the surface. It requires a deep dive into traffic laws, evidence gathering, and aggressive negotiation with insurance companies that want to protect their bottom line.
If you or a loved one has been injured in a side-impact collision in Miami or the surrounding areas, do not try to handle the insurance adjusters alone. Put the experience of a multi-award-winning, Black-owned law firm in your corner. We will help you recover just compensation for your medical bills, lost wages, and your physical and emotional pain.
Lett Law Firm Blog











